subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Tue, Nov 10 2009 

Resources

print this story   Print this story
  Post to del.icio.us

Published July 31, 2008 10:53 pm -

City clarifies animal shelter project costs


By D. E. Smoot
Phoenix Staff Writer

The architect who designed Muskogee’s animal shelter challenged recent comments made by a second architect hired to design expansion and repair plans for the facility.

Mike Martin of Spaces, Design and Architecture said claims that faulty fill materials were used during the original construction of the shelter were ill-informed. Martin described comments about the animal shelter’s conditions as speculative and misleading.

In addition to disputing claims of faulty construction, Martin criticized reports from which it could be inferred that much of the costs associated with the expansion would be spent for corrective measures. City officials clarified that only a small percentage of the $142,750 price tag for construction will be spent for the repair of original construction.

Architect Roger Richter was paid $13,500 for the expansion plans designed in part to correct problems at the shelter and add additional space for the animals. He recently told city councilors the animal shelter was built upon “unsuitable fill material.”

City Manager Greg Buckley said there is an area from which base-clay material was pulled, but without spending several thousand dollars, it would be impossible to know the exact nature of the fill material.

Martin, however, presented documents this week that indicate the fill material, described as “fat clay” by Richter, actually consists of gray and tan shale. Those documents, prepared by an independent laboratory, indicate use of the shale was approved by city officials and on-site tests met required specifications.

The concrete slab upon which the animal shelter stands, Martin said, shows no signs he can see of upheaval or bowing.

City councilors were told in July the floor had bowed upward as a result of the alleged presence of clay and a high volume of water that had collected beneath the shelter.

Martin said the floor was designed to rise toward the middle so that animal wastes would gravitate toward the back of the runs into a trough sloped toward one end of the building for easier removal. That specification, Martin said, was requested by those who were to operate the animal shelter once it was completed.

“The center drains were not intended to accept any wastes from the kennels,” Martin said. “Those drains were designed to carry the excess water swept toward the center after the animal runs were hosed down. They (the drains) are not inoperable, you just have to understand the way they were intended to work.”

Martin said he designed the animal shelter in accordance with the specifications “dictated to me 14 years ago. People today are not taking that into consideration.” All work, he said, was approved by city inspectors.

Buckley said the city engineer’s research found the floor was designed to slope upward toward the center where the drains are located. To determine whether the present slope is more or less than it was when the shelter was built, Buckley said, would be pure speculation at this point.”

Ward IV Councilor Jim Ritchey said he has investigated the problems at the animal shelter since they became apparent a few months ago.



print this story    email this story   






autoconx
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide


Premier Guide

Premium Jobs

5270-Maintenance Technician
MAINTENANCE
TECHNICIAN

Whitlock Packaging Corporation, a juice manufacturing company located in Fort Gib
...>MORE

5323-Delivery Driver


DELIVERY DRIVER
Eufaula, Oklahoma
Starting pay $14.50 hr
+ incentive pay

- Must ha
...>MORE

5356-Acccounting Technicians
ACCOUNTING
TECHNICIANS
Seeking applications for one Full Time Accounting Technician for a job located in Musko
...>MORE

5269-RN
RN
Are you looking for the Great Pay, Full Benefits, Stability, and Strong Reputation of a large company without th
...>MORE

5385-Maintenance Electrician
V & M TCA, a division of V & M Star, L.P.

MAINTENANCE ELECTRICIAN

Qualified applicants must posses
...>MORE

See all ads

Premium Autos

5335-2008 Yamaha
2008 Yamaha Rafter 700 SC Red & White, $6,000 - 2007 Yamaha Rafter 700 Blue - $5,000 or both $10,000 OBO. Great conditio...>MORE

See all ads

Premium Extras

5359 8n tractor
8N tractor, with 2 bottom plow, rebuilding, new radiator & all parts to rbuild $1000. 918-464-2266 ask for Bill....>MORE

5378 1993 motor home
1993 Motor Home, 21ft, sleeps 6, Toyota cyl., powered fully equipped with generator $7000. 2 Suzuki ATV, 500cc, 4 wheele...>MORE

5371-AKC Old English Sheepdog
AKC Old English Sheepdog, OFA - hips, microchip, some blue eyes, genetic testing - $600-$700. Call 903-361-8766 or 903-3...>MORE

5377-2000 Dodge
2000 Dodge Caravan handicap-ramp-hand controls, new tires & battery $2750. 918-682-4004....>MORE

5364 2001 bass tracker
2001 Bass Tracker, pro crappie, 175, w/2003, 40hp mercury,power tilt, & trim, 2 life wells & 2 bait wells,fish locater,m...>MORE

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2009. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index