subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Wed, May 14 2008 

Published February 21, 2008 06:10 pm -

Congresswoman takes heroic freedmen stance


By Marilyn Vann
Guest Columnist

Cherokee Nation Chief Chad Smith and his supporters denounced HR 2824 by U.S. Rep. Diane Watson, D-Calif. The bill is designed to strip federal funding from the tribe if it denationalizes Cherokee freedmen citizens.

An ethics complaint against Watson states the bill oversteps her authority. Smith called the congresswoman an outsider who misrepresents facts, and stated that the 1866 Treaty was forced on the Cherokee Nation. Some Cherokee leaders even called HR 2824 a “termination” bill. Smith supporters stated Cherokees want only “Indians” in the tribe. Smith stated that Cherokee freedmen who received land allotments received “reparations.”

The U.S. Supreme Court upholds Congress’ right to pass laws affecting Indian tribes, including federal funding. Cherokee leaders never classed congressional members as “outsiders” who supported bills they requested — including an act which removed United Keetoowah Band’s federal funding.

In 1866, to re-establish relations with the United States, the Cherokee Nation signed a reconstruction treaty granting “the rights of Native Cherokees” to slaves and free blacks living within the tribe in 1861 and their descendants. Federal cases (Redbird, Whitmire) have held that Cherokee freed-men were granted citizenship by treaty and that freedmen citizenship was not forced on the tribe.

Chief Smith states the treaty agreement was forced. Does he believe in the Confederate’s policy of slavery and that the tribe should still have that right?

Smith falsely states that Cherokee freedmen received tribal allotments as reparations. Historically Cherokee citizens owned land in common. Cherokee freedmen received shares of common lands just as other Cherokee citizens — which is no different than that of freed slaves of Confederates who received U.S. citizenship and could receive federal land under the Homestead Act.

Clearly, Cherokee freedmen, whose ancestors came across the Trail of Tears on foot, carrying baggage, shackled and who toiled unpaid for generations, receiving the same equal rights as native Cherokee was reasonable by both the Cherokee Nation and the United States. Both Cherokee Indians and freedmen received U.S. citizenship in 1901.

Smith’s references to Cherokee freedmen as “non-Indians” are misleading. Cherokee freedmen, regardless of “Indian ancestry” or lack of, have legal citizenship guaranteed by the tribe and America. The Dawes rolls listed Cherokee tribal members living between 1902 and 1906 for land allotment purposes and were not simply lists of Indians and non-Indians.

HR2824 is not a termination bill. If passed it will not shut down the tribal council or courts, or remove the chief. The tribe is not forced to continue freedmen citizenship. But if passed the tribe loses federal funding and casino operation rights if not in compliance with the 1866 Treaty. Funding and casino rights will continue after legal compliance.

Cherokee freedmen have treaty rights of federal intervention to protect our tribal citizenship. The Cherokee Nation, which annual receives $300 million in federal funding, has spent millions lobbying Congress under Smith’s leadership to denationalize its slave descendants.

Congresswoman Watson’s brave decision to help the freedmen is like members of Congress who helped black citizens of Mississippi during the Civil Rights Movement. She is a heroine for justice of people who have been overlooked and discarded.

If Smith succeeds in breaking the treaty agreement for freedmen citizenship, he will send a termination message to those who desire to have the United States end tribal governments by declaring all Indian treaties void.

No tribe will be safe.

Marilyn Vann is president of the Descendants of Freedmen Association Click Here



print this story    email this story    comment on this story   

Click to discuss this story with other readers on our forums.




monster
wheels
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide


Find a job! Find a Home! Find a car!

Premier Guide

Premium Jobs

1488-Administrative Assistant
Bacone College is looking for a full-time Administrative Assistant for the School of Health Sciences. Hours 8am-5pm, Mon...>MORE

1492-CNC Machinist/Assemblers
BALDOR ELECTRIC in Westville, OK is now hiring on all three shifts for the following full-time positions:
CNC Machi
...>MORE

1341-Technicians
Accepting applications for Field & Cleaning Technicians. Competitive pay, training on site and medical benefits. Must be...>MORE

1482-Casino Security Officers
Muscogee (Creek) Nation Gaming Security is now taking applications for Security Officers. Qualifications: Must be 21 yea...>MORE

1483-Salesperson
SALESPERSON wanted for a fast growing Toyota Dealership. We offer a great pay plan, Insurance and 401K Applicant must: h...>MORE

1472-Nurses & CHHAs
NURSES AND CERTIFIED HOME HEALTH AIDES - Competitive Wages, Mileage Reimbursement. MED-CORP HOME HEALTH, INC.
Conta
...>MORE

1485-Dental/Hygiene Assistant
Dental/Hygiene Assistant with Coronal Polishing and X-ray experience preferred. Fax resume to 918-683-5111....>MORE

1484-Office Help
Office help needed. Apply in person Friday or Monday at 165 Auto Auction, 3631 Peak Blvd. in Muskogee....>MORE

1476-Lawn Care
Man wanted to mow lawn and take care of flowers and gardening. Also do general handy man work and some brush hog work. P...>MORE

1493-Portrait Photographer
Shugart Studios, Inc. (No Photography Experience Required). Part-Time & Full Time Available. Fun and Creative Environmen...>MORE

1468-HTS
HTS - Oklahoma MENTOR is seeking reliable, compassionate staff that have a background working with individuals with deve...>MORE

1494-Personal Care Assistant
Seeking mature & dependable Personal Care Assistant in the Oktaha, Checotah and Hitchita Areas. $7.50 per hour. Call Mar...>MORE

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2008. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index

rc