subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Fri, Jul 18 2008 

Published April 29, 2008 04:25 pm - The bill in no way “creates a voucher system.”

School-choice bill misunderstood by 30


By Brandon Dutcher
Guest Columnist

A recent letter signed by 30 superintendents of eastern Oklahoma school districts (Phoenix April 24 Opinion Page) was critical of Senate Bill 2093, the New Hope Scholarship Act.

The bill would give a tax credit to taxpayers who contribute to organizations that provide private-school scholarships for low-income children currently attending failing public schools in Oklahoma City and Tulsa.

The superintendents wrongly assert that the bill “creates a voucher system that would take public dollars and transfer them through the use of tax credits to private schools.”

The bill in no way “creates a voucher system.”

A voucher is like a food stamp. Just as recipients of food stamps can redeem them at the grocery store of their choice, school vouchers (education stamps, if you will) allow parents to take government money and spend it at the school of their choice. There are currently 14 school voucher programs operating in nine states, so there’s no excuse for these superintendents not to comprehend what a voucher system is.

Moreover, the New Hope tax credit doesn’t involve “public dollars.” It involves money that goes from your checkbook to a private charity.

It never goes near the state treasury. As the Arizona Supreme Court ruled — and the U.S. Supreme Court let stand — in a school-choice tax credit case in 1999, “public money” is revenue the government actually receives. “Thus,” the Court ruled, “under any common understanding of the words, we are not here dealing with ‘public money.’” We’re dealing with the donations of generous Oklahomans who want to give new hope to children trapped in the worst schools in these districts where the graduation rate is an appalling 50 percent.

By the superintendents’ way of reasoning, your entire paycheck consists of “public dollars,” and you should be thankful that they let you keep any of them.

The superintendents also claim that “the end result is still fewer resources left for those students who remain in public schools.” The opposite is true. There will be more resources — not fewer — left for those students who remain in public schools.

As Dr. Susan Aud explains, “When a student uses school choice, the local public school district no longer needs to pay the instructional costs associated with that student, but it does not lose all of its per-student revenue, because some revenue does not vary with enrollment levels. Thus, school choice produces a positive fiscal impact for school districts ... Instructional spending per student has consistently gone up in all affected public school districts and states. School choice has not prevented those states and districts from spending more on the students who remain in public schools.”

Indeed, if the superintendents had done their homework, they would have discovered that under the New Hope bill per-pupil funding increases by approximately $38.

The superintendents also say the bill represents an “all-out attack” on public education, an odd claim considering the bill would affect 0.16 percent of the state’s students.

All in all, a pretty sloppy performance for a group of folks with doctoral degrees.

Brandon Dutcher is vice president for policy at the Oklahoma Council of Public Affairs and editor of Choice Remarks (Click Here).



print this story    email this story    comment on this story   

Click to discuss this story with other readers on our forums.




monster
wheels
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide


Find a job! Find a Home! Find a car!

Premier Guide

Premium Jobs

2026-Assistant/Receptionist
Part-time in Optometry office. Will train. Accepting resumes. Dr. Baggs in Arrowhead Mall, Suite 36B in Muskogee....>MORE

2035-Dozer & Track Hoe
Experienced operators are needed for work in the Muskogee area. Excellent pay with benefits.
Call (318) 525-4283.
...>MORE

2049-Cherokee Nation
POSITIONS AVAILABLE:
*Registered Nurse
Advantage Waiver
Regular Full Time
*Registered Physical Thera
...>MORE

2064-Plumbers
Journeyman and Apprentice needed for large local project. Paid vacation/holiday after 1 year, health ins., 401K, paid we...>MORE

2087-Construction/Maintenance Technician
Oklahoma School for the Blind has an opening for Construction/ Maintenance Technician, Level II. (Re-announcement). Prev...>MORE

2052-Salesperson
Cooper Furniture is accepting applications for a Salesperson with retail experience. Apply in person at 11th & Shawnee. ...>MORE

2057-Excel Therapy
Physical Therapist
Physical Therapy Assistant
Excel Therapy has 3 immediate full-time positions available: a P
...>MORE

2065-Marketer
Home Health Agency in need of a marketer person to market for the Muskogee and surrounding area. Please e-mail resume to...>MORE

2012-Secretary
Needed for office help Mon-Fri 9am-5pm. Some computer skills required. Pay based on experience
Apply in person:
...>MORE

2027-Lawn Crew
Now hiring Lawn Crew personnel.
Applications may be completed at 220 North 40th Street. Valid driver's license req
...>MORE

2086-Prevention Specialist
The Muskogee Community Anti-Drug Network seeks a full-time Prevention Specialist. A Bachelors Degree or equivalent exper...>MORE

2045-Physical Therapist Opportunities
The Kelly Todd Cerebral Palsy Center in Muskogee, Oklahoma has immediate openings for full-time and part-time Physical T...>MORE

See all ads

Premium Autos

2025-1991 Chevy Van
New tires, good motor, does need side window. $1100 OBO. 918-683-2538...>MORE

2034-Motorcycle
2006 Honda Shadow 600cc 400 actual miles. Red. $5000 OBO 918-683-0021...>MORE

See all ads

Premium Real Estate

2068-Janitorial Manager
Evening janitorial manager wanted for Muskogee area. Must be bilingual in English and Spanish.
Call 918-857-3388.
...>MORE

See all ads

Premium Extras

2014-Jack Russell Puppies
Registered, adorable $125. shots & wormed
918-441-6889 or 441-4511.
...>MORE

2036-Torkie Puppies
$200 each Shots & wormed, cute.
918-689-3925.
...>MORE

2024-Car & Electric Bed
1990 Toyota Tercel 43 miles per gallon, also have nice twin size electric bed for sale $150, Car $2000. 601 North C. 918...>MORE

2006-Lease of Pasture for Grazing Cattle
$10 a head per month. Call 918-482-1705 or
Hardy White @ 918-521-1952
...>MORE

2067-2004 Jayco Flight RV
2004 Jayco Flight, 28 ft 5th wheel, large slide out, clean. Asking $16,800 918-869-6888 or 687-8081...>MORE

2085-Yorkies
Male Yorkie, Tiny or Tea Cup Docshires, Shorkies, York A Poo. $150-$650. 8weeks up Cash!
918-487-5660.441-1172.
...>MORE

2039-John Deere Tractor
54hp, gas, on 3020 Chassis, recent overhaul, field ready. PTO 3pt, PS, $6500 obo. 918-484-2364....>MORE

2070-Chihuahuas...
Toy Poodles, Maltese, MinSchnauzers
918-869-8418 or 348-2595
credit card accepted
...>MORE

2078-Broke Palomino mare
Dun mare with stud colt, 2 geldings
918-689-9524 or 617-0454
...>MORE

2009-Whirlpool Washer & Dryer
4 years old, bisque color, runs perfectly. $300
call 918-681-4662
...>MORE

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2008. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index

rc